Tuesday, February 13, 2024

A change to this blog's flight plan...

A ton of things to be featured are lying on their dedicated space on my HDD for a good long while now, while other things just come up in the moment, while I post some of those first things. In more plain words: I tend to get distracted. Which is not necessarily a bad thing, since it means I'm still discovering and researching and reworking on the fly. Life is constant flux, so why should a music blog be any different. All this is a long-winded way to say that when I posted Yes' From A Page (A Single Page) a week ago that got me thinking of the Drama and Fly From Here era bands, which in turn got me interested in the origins of the latter album's centerpiece. I knew it was based on a piece Trevor Horn and Geoffrey Downes a.k.a. The Buggles had presented to Yes and occasionally played live on the Drama tour before that specific version of Yes, lovingly dubbed BugglYes by me as opposed to other fans' more dismissive-sounding The Yeggles, disbanded. It turns out that "We Can Fly From Here" has a much bigger importance for Mrs. Horn and Downes than initially thought, which also explains why that song is the thread that binds the two bands together, over a time span of almost forty years. 

"We Can Fly From here" has the distinction of directly and indirectly starting two bands: According to Horn's introductions in concert, it was the first song the Buggles ever wrote together, then became the song that got them the gig as the bulkheads of Drama-era Yes. They never got to finish a version of "We Can Fly From Here" for their debut album Adventures in Plastic, but - like other tracks - noticed how, well, proggish the song sounded and, having the same manager, decided to offer the song to Yes, who had recently suffered the defections of Jon Anderson and Rick Wakeman. Whether the Buggles were angling for this or not, their meeting to offer "We Can Fly From Here" to Yes turned into the remains of Yes offering them a place in the band. A demo version of the song was produced in 1980, but the song seemngly wasn't developed much further and never made it onto Drama, though some archival live recordings exist. Horns and Downes then cut an impressive, elaborate demo in 1981 for possible inclusion on the second Buggles album, Adventures In Modern Recording, but this didn't come to pass, either. Basically , Horn and Downes decided to end their collaboration and Horn finished the album alone, with only three tracks featuring Downes, none of them "We Can Fly From Here". And then that was it, for a long time, for the song that started it all. 

Songs that have such a personal importance for its authors tend to die hard, though, and it seems obvious that Horn never really let the song go entirely.. So when the band reconnected with him in the late 2000s (after having been produced by him through their 1980s chart-making era, a.k.a. the Trevor Rabin years) and where throwing ideas around for a new studio album, Horn brought "We Can Fly From Here" up. Soon the idea was born to turn the original ideas into a long-form piece rivaling their early to mid-70s work, to be further developed from The Buggles' original demos. Oliver Wakeman, the keys man at the time was gently asked to leave to make place for Geoff Downes, because the latter was supposed to have a "greater sensibility for the material". Duh. Also brutally ironic, considering that Wakeman the Younger had suggested to contact Horn to begin with. The songs he developed finally ended up on From A Page, as mentioned in the intro. And so, BugglYes was reborn, or almost. 

Having recruited David Benoit from a Yes cover band to replace Jon Anderson a couple of years earlier, the first version of "Fly From Here", the long-form suite, featured him singing on the album that was named after it, 2011's Fly From Here. But the BugglYes were not quite done yet, and Horn still didn't have this song that was so close to his heart, in the form that he - secretly or not so secretly - wanted. After having unceremoniously fired Benoit for falling ill (history repeating itself for Yes vocalists), Horn - parallel to the band touring with Jon Davison - returned to Fly From Here and recorded replacement vocals for the entire album, including its centerpiece "Fly From Here" suite. The result, complete with new mixing and guitar and keyboard overdubs, was released in 2018 as Fly From Here: Return Flight. And, finally, after almost 40 years, the BugglYes had finally won. Their baby, the first song Horn and Downes wrote together, was finally out - with Horn on vocals and Downes on keyboards, like back in 1979. To be honest, I prefer the original 2011 version of the suite and Benoit's vocals, which seem more emotional and expressive, whereas Horn's vocals are more robotic, perhaps wilfully so, perhaps not. 

So, the album of the day. At four tracks it is probably more of an EP, though at 40 minutes length it's having classic album length. It captures the journey of the BugglYes' work on "We Can Fly From Here" from the relatively rudimentary first demo which is supposed to be Yes, but it's not obvious who besides Horn and Downes is playing on it. Even the drums could easily be a drum machine. Then, off to a live version from the same year's Drama tour, followed by the more elaborate demo Horns and Downes cut in 1981 and finally the suite from Fly From Here: Return Flight in slightly altered form. Some of the transitions of the suite were really iffy and not particularly thought out, glued together with an old piece of chewing gum and some duct tape. So I worked on the suite to get rid of some of these pretty bad transitions and tightened up the thing by eliminating some slow spots and redundancies (including the first part of Steve Howe's "Bumpy Ride" section, which was really badly integrated into the piece). "Fly From Here" is now coming in at a little over 19 minutes, almost five minutes less than the original. I think it works better that way. 

Looking at the journey of the song from its admittedly wobbly beginnings, I'm mightily impressed with The Buggles' version of the song, which probably convinced Yes in 2010 that there was something there. On the suite you can still trace back its opening parts to the demos from 1980 and 1981 and make some other fun observations, like how it takes the chord progressions of "Machine Messiah" at one point in a callback to Drama (starting from the "Sailor...sailor beware" section at 12.50 and re-appearing several times in the four minutes that follow). Spending an entire LP's worh of time on a single song and its progression can only work if that song is worth it, and I think that "We Can Fly" in all its incarnations is worth it. 

I'll let you discover if you agree. Ready For Takeoff in 3-2-1... 



3 comments:

  1. You Can Fly From Here:

    https://workupload.com/file/qk9SWytUzuW

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks OBG, I'm in agreement with you about Drama, it's a very fine album, so this should be worth listening too. And I'll give From a Page a spin too.

    ReplyDelete

Bob Carpenter Tries One More Time...(And Nobly Fails, One More Time)

Last we talked about  Bob Carpenter  we relayed the sad, maddening story surrounding the release of his only official record, the amazing Si...