And I mean that literally. Don't let it be said that I don't recognize the trace of a good idea if I stumble upon one. My use of alternate takes including pedal steel and violin when reconfiguring Pink Floyd's Wish You Were Here tempted a reader (hi, Thames!) to declare it a country album, which - while not strictly accurate - does capture the different feel of that version. It also left me with a new idea: What about making a real, dyed-in-the-wool country album of Pink Floyd tunes. And here it is: Welcome To Pink Floyd Country?
There were two problems with the plan: first of all, there were way less country covers of Pink Floyd songs than I imagined - maybe that match made in heaven wasn't as obvious as I made it out to be? And secondly, of those that existed, there was a rather uneven playing field: I could probably fill a compilation with covers of "Wish You Were Here" and "Time" alone, as these two are by far the most popular cover song choices, including some country & bluegrass artists. But I wanted a variety of songs, so no doubles, not counting the pedal steel version of "Wish You Were Here" of the band itself that was all over the OBG Edit of Wish You Were Here, and is here in all its unaltered, full glory.
But I did find enough good stuff to complete This Is Pink Floyd Country. One thing that was interesting is that more than half of the tracks on here come from The Wall. I wouldn't have thought that at first, thinking that tracks from Dark Side Of The Moon would outnumber them, but that was definitely wrong - "Time" excluded. Though, to be fair, I took a full four tracks from a single band and album: Luther Wright & The Wrongs covered the entire Wall album in a bluegrass style, though I'm still not quite sure whether the whole thing is an elaborate piss-take on the album or an honest, if definitely idiosyncratic take on it. There is definitely a touch too much of country humour in Mr. Wright's voice, but I took the tracks that sound the most genuine, while definitely bringing the country instrumentation in spades.
I'm already on the record as declaring Cornbread Red's take on "Comfortably Numb" as my favorite take on the song - ever. But there are also great takes on "Mother" by main Dixie Chick Natalie Maines and a really nice run through "Run Like Hell" by multi-instrumentalist David West (he also adds a great take on "See Emily Play"). Wish You Were Here is represented by Cody Jinks' fantastic take on the title song, again led by a majestic pedal steel, showing how that song would have turned out if David Gilmour was a redneck (and I mean that in the best possible way), as well as prog bluegrass band Kitchen Dwellers' take on "Welcome To The Machine". Out of the "Time" covers I chose the one by Cash Dawson, who really brings a nicely atmospheric alt country/Americana vibe to it. And finally, there's Billy Strings with an awesome, extended take on "Fearless".
So, cool cover, cool cover versions, here's This Is Pink Floyd Country for your delectation...



Favorite cover of a Pink Floyd song (country or not)?
ReplyDeleteHERE'S THE NEW AND IMPROVED LINK
Deletehttps://workupload.com/file/aeeymfdUxNB
As Jeff just underneath pointed out, there was an issue with the file, most likely an error during compression. I tried to download my own file twice to check, and twice the download didn't finish correctly.
This should do it, if not, let me know.
Time is a zero-byte file — can you please reupload?
ReplyDeleteYup, lots of bluegrass Pink Floyd out there.
ReplyDeleteFor my favorite cover, I really like Polka Floyd's See Emily Play.
Back in 1977 I was trying to do a cover of "Ring of Fire" as if it were a Burning Spear meets the Clash thing, but we lacked the talent to pull it off.
ReplyDeleteI suppose no surviving tapes in a garage somewhere? Maybe wde can turn your former band into a hitherto undiscovered sensation?
DeleteNo, unfortunately. It was a good idea; still is, actually.
DeleteIt's true that Cash's classic 'boom-tchick-boom' rhythm should easily translate into a ska rhythm. So draftervoi, draft some guys and get on it!
DeleteKorn's cover of 'Another Brick In the Wall'
ReplyDelete