Time to check back in with one of the venerated perfomers on our beloved All Pearls No Swine series. Barbara Keith wasn't as obscure a name as some of the others featured on the very first APNs, but she made herself obscure by simply vanishing at the tie he brought out the album that could and should have been her big breakthrough. Keith had played the folk clubs of Greenwich village, before playing with the folk-rock combo Kangaroo, led by future Orleans-leader John Hall, who published an album in 1968. She then recorded her self-titled debut for Verve Forecast, which had some decent numbers on it, though nothing exceptionally striking. Allmusic's Richie Unterberger is right, when he says that it is " respectable, slightly above-average singer/songwriter musicn with a strong country-rock flacor", the latter of which of course pleasing the One Buck Guy.
But the real stunner came, when three years later she recorded and released another self-titled album, this time on Reprise. As one would imagine from a Warner Brothers/Reprise recording, the cream of players showed up to help out, including Lowell George (whose slide elevates Keith's classic "Detroit Or Buffalo"), Lee Sklar, as well as Spooner Oldham and Stinky Pete Kleinow on pedal steel.
"All Along The Watchtower" is a truly intriguing take on Dylan's classic, including some electronic effects that imitate the growling cat. The paranoid, apocalyptic atmosphere of the song really comes through and if Keith's version has a minor fault, it's that it fades out too quickly, just as the electric guitars start to get going. "The Bramble And The Rose" is a superior ballad,as is "Rainy Nights Are All The Same", and I've already talked about what a great song "Detroit Or Buffalo" is, as it was done by both One Buck Records-featured Bruce Stephens and Neal Casal. The gospel-inspired "Burn The Midnight Oil No More" or the anthemic "Free The People", almost immediately covered by Delaney & Bonnie - Barabar Keith is taking the 'all killer, no filler' concept to heart here.
Despite the quality of the album - ten tracks, some classics, none less than very good - there was one major critic of the album - Barbara Keith herself. "It didn't feel like me yet, and so we gave back the album advance money and quit". Keith had just married Keith Tibbles, the songwriting partner of the album's producer Larry Marks, and - with the album somehow not matching the sound she imagined for herself, Keith up and went and quit the music business entirely, to start a family with Tibbles. With Keith dropping out, Reprise did little to no promotion for the album and it was almost immediately withdrawn, only adding to the album's myth. For years and years there were no signs of Keith, then 25 years later she resurfaced with the family band The Stone Coyotes, consisting of Tibbles and her stepson, as a local attraction in the Springfield, Massachussets area. But that's another story.
Now, I don't know what could have probably been Keith's problem with the album, as everything here is top-notch: Keith's songwriting, with only the Dylan number coming from the outside, the production, the playing. This is nothing less than fantastic. Then again, so was The La's' only album (the curse of the self-titled albums?), and Lee Mavers couldn't hear it, and also dropped out. Whaddayaknow, right?! Either way, listen to this, and tell me I'm wrong.
In addition to the classic 1972 eponymous (there! I said it!) album you'll get a whooping twelve bonus tracks, eleven tracks from the debut album and its singles, as well as a modern remix of "All Along The Watchtower". I didn't include the two Kangaroo tracks, as their acid rock fuzz guitar intermezzos, even within Keith's folk-rockn don't really match with the rest of the music here, though fans of that type of music can probably worse than checking it out. But befor these extracurricular studies, check out Barbara Keith and wonder with me how she could possibly quit the music business with that album in the bag.




























.jpg)


















