About three years ago - and more or less by circumstance - I did an interesting experiment. More or less simultaneously I entered not once but twice that most perilious of adventures - a sequel to Alan Moore's comic book classic Watchmen. Unlike some other lauded revisionist superhero comics of the era (here's looking at you, The Dark Knight Returns) Watchmen has held up exceptionally well. Moore's mastery of form and storytelling, as well as a knack for giving these somewhat abstract characters complicated inner lives is so complete, that usually once per year I reread bits of Watchmen, not the entire thing letter to letter, but passages I like or get sucked into.
For years the idea of doing a sequel to Moore's lauded (and loaded) requiem for the supehero seemed an impossible task. Who would be courageous or foolish enough to try and match Moore's masterwork? The first shots were of course fired by DC, corporate greed and all that. They story of how they screwed Moore out of ownership of Watchmen is well-known, and after about two decades they decided that now it was time to do something about that old yet valuable IP. So was born a Watchmen project that included a half-dozen Before Watchmen prequel series, only to then culminate in a huge maxiseries called Doomsday Clock. Which is what I read, along with the TV sequel series called Watchmen by - oh my - one of the guys who fucked up Lost.
Results were mixed, but not necessarily in the way I expected. Doomsday Clock had its strong points, starting with artist Gary Frank whose detailled, semi-realist pencil work I have always loved and whose work here is boss all the way through. It also has its moments: I had fun with the new Marionette and Mime characters in the early chapters (which unfortunately build to vey little in the end), and individual characters and scenes, like Moth Man and his fate, were surprisingly moving. But there's no denying that Doomsday Clock also was kind of a slog to read. I read the trade paperback, so I could just plow on, but I imagine how frustrating it must've been to read this slow-moving series in monthly installments (not to mention that in between schedule-shifting and pushing back of issues, the series which was supposed to run its 12 issues in less than a year took two to complete!). In Watchmen, Moore designed every chapter around a character, but every chapter moved the bigger mystery further. Each chapter was both a satisfying, complete read in itself, and an important part of the puzzle. This elegance of design is something that author Geoff Johns can not imitate.
It's not for lack of trying. The imitation, that is. Doomsday Clock slavishly imitates some of Moore's storytelling devices. These installments are, like Moore's original series, 32 pages long, for no other reason than to mimic the original, much like Moore's and Dave Gibboons' famous nine-panel grids. As said, the plotting isn't up to par, though, confused and confusing, losing sights of some of its early seeming lead characters and finally ends up as everyone thought it would: a rather underwhelming confrontation between Superman and Doctor Manhattan. Doomsday Clock is beautifully drawn and presented, but a complete muddle of a story, and finally a sign of what's wrong with DC's revival of the Watchmen brand: It's pure IP management, treating the original with reverence, but itself becoming a musuem piece with nothing much to say, or add to the original, really. Par of the course, in a way, uperheroes and less than super heroes forever trapped in ember.
Watchmen, the series, was something else, though. Damon Lindelof went about this without the staid reverence of Doomsday Clock, telling its own stand-alone story in the universe of the Watchmen. This can, especially at the beginning, seem odd. The series wastes no time establishing racial conflict as the story ctalyst, set against the backdrop of the Watchmen universe some thirty years later. It's a storytelling device that lands with astounding predictive power, considering the George Floyd protests and the subsequent Black Lives Matter-movement were just months away from the broadcast of the series. Some of the aspects of this - a white supremacist group taking Rohrschach and his at times borderline fascist behavior as their idol and patron saint - are intelligent extensions of the original text. Which really summarizes the series as a whole. Lindeloff called it a 'remix' set in the Watchmen universe, and he's right, but most of the extra material he brings in is well thought out and makes sense. But more importantly: it all feels vital.
If there is a big difference in sense and sensibility between Doomsday Clock and the Watchmen TV show, it's because one feels slavishly retro and static, while the other is constantly interesting and moving. One can argue that not all of it lands - I found some of the stuff involving a certain Asian character a little too much 'out there' - but man, is Lindelof taking big swings with this one, and there are way more hits than misses. But the difference to Doomsday Clock is right there: Where the comic book, as comic books and their publishers are wont to do, basically takes a veryl ong tour to maintain the status quo, Lindeloff rattles a bunch of foundations of the Watchmen universe to find new uestions and new answers. I'll leave it at that to not spoil, because if you haven't seen the Watchmen tv series, be sure to do so, it is without exagerration one of the best tv shows of the last years. Beware that you should have at least working knowledge of the Watchmen comic (not Zack Snyder's half-impressive half-ridiculous film) because Lindeloff bases his series on that. Otherwise the squid rain machine will leave you puzzled (...or even more puzzled!).
All of this is a very longwinded way to get to the One Buck Record of the day, but there is some music coming, I promise! Because one part of the Watchmen tv series' vitality is its propulsive soundtrack courtesy of Mr. Nine Inch Nails Trent Reznor and partner in crime Atticus Ross. These two have collaborated on a number of soundtracks - from The Social Network to The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo - and as usual, this is a fully electronic affair. It's also really good stuff! But stuff that wasn't originally presented very well. Reznor and Ross issued the soundtrack as three records, but there seemed to be no real guiding principle or thought put into the tracklist and sequencing. Some of the tracks didn't feature in the series, none of them were chronologically arranged and really it felt like 'here's some cool music from the show' rather than a designed soundtrack.
Enter the One Buck Guy. I wanted to give the score by Mrs. Reznor & Ross its due, while also highlighting some of the at times great needle drops the series provides. So, mixed in with the score you will find artists as diverse as Orville Peck, Devo, Howard Jones, Desmond Dekker, Irma Thomas, Sturgill Simpson, Hall & Oates, Zambian rock band WITCH, Kenny Rogers & Dolly Parton, Spooky Tooth, and, uh, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. I also kept and mixed in some of the little sound bites and series dialogue issued on the soundtracks for maximum immersion in the show. The other big thing is that I present this music as a number of suites, one for every episode of the show. Some are longer, some are shorter, some have a number of needle drops, some just one (and the opening track "Summer, No Ice" none). The music is presented as chronologically as possible, and also imitates the show's use of musical themes and leitmotive, so some bits will come up several times, such as the theme of series protagonist Angela Abar a.k.a.Sister Midnight.
The great intelligence and eye for detail extends to the musical choices of the show. Just one example: In the mid-seson episode "Little Fear Of Lightning" cop Wade Templeman a.k.a. Looking Glass (a really great Tim Blake Nelson) goes into a redneck roadside bar to hook up with a lady (but not all is what it seems) and as a soundtrack for that bar scene, any ol' country tune would have worked. But the powers that be chose Sturgill Simpson's "Turtles All The Way Down" (very recently featured in a bluegrass version on my Americana compilation) with its line about "reptile aliens made of light", which perfectly captures Tillman's defining feature, post traumatic stress syndrome after the giant Alien Squid attack he witnessed and thus his panicked fear of other alien attacks.
If you have seen Watchmen the tv series, these nine suites will hopefully transport you back into the series. And if you haven't, they will hopefully inspire you to check that series out. And you are winning either way, because there is some very fine music in here, both from Reznor & Ross and from the illustruous group dropping in.
So, who watches the Watchmen? Hopefully you, soon. And who listens to the Watchmen? Hopefully, you too, soon.